论文标题

将人类和分析反馈相结合对学生参与和表现的反思性写作任务的影响

Impact of combining human and analytics feedback on students' engagement with, and performance in, reflective writing tasks

论文作者

Suraworachet, Wannapon, Zhou, Qi, Cukurova, Mutlu

论文摘要

反思性写作是全球许多高等教育课程的一部分。对于学生来说,通常被认为是一项具有挑战性的任务,因为它需要自我调节的学习技能才能适当计划,及时参与并深入思考学习经验。尽管旨在支持学生思考的人类反馈的撰写分析和普遍存在,但对如何整合人类和分析的反馈知之甚少,以改善学生在反思性写作任务中的学习参与和表现。这项研究提出了一种个性化的行为反馈干预措施,基于学生的写作参与分析,利用无处不在的在线文字处理平台对数字痕迹的时间序列分析。在一项为期一个学期的实验研究中,研究了其对学习参与和表现的影响。结果表明,与对照组相比,干预队列在收到合并的反馈后,在反思性写作任务上的参与度更高,而对照组仅收到了人类对其反思性写作内容的反馈。进一步的分析表明,干预队列在每周水平上更定期地反思,每周反思的规律性导致表现更好,并且对低自我调节学习能力的学生的影响较高。这项研究强调了实施组合反馈方法的有力好处,在这种方法中,合成了分析和人类反馈的优势以改善学生的参与和表现。进一步的研究应探讨在其他情况下观察到的影响及其有效性的长期可持续性。

Reflective writing is part of many higher education courses across the globe. It is often considered a challenging task for students as it requires self-regulated learning skills to appropriately plan, timely engage and deeply reflect on learning experiences. Despite an advance in writing analytics and the pervasiveness of human feedback aimed to support student reflections, little is known about how to integrate feedback from humans and analytics to improve students' learning engagement and performance in reflective writing tasks. This study proposes a personalised behavioural feedback intervention based on students' writing engagement analytics utilising time-series analysis of digital traces from a ubiquitous online word processing platform. In a semester-long experimental study involving 81 postgraduate students, its impact on learning engagement and performance was studied. The results showed that the intervention cohort engaged statistically significantly more in their reflective writing task after receiving the combined feedback compared to the control cohort which only received human feedback on their reflective writing content. Further analyses revealed that the intervention cohort reflected more regularly at the weekly level, the regularity of weekly reflection led to better performance grades, and the impact on students with low self-regulated learning skills was higher. This study emphasizes the powerful benefits of implementing combined feedback approaches in which the strengths of analytics and human feedback are synthesized to improve student engagement and performance. Further research should explore the long-term sustainability of the observed effects and their validity in other contexts.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源