论文标题
新闻来源可靠性的新闻评估的结构化分析
A Structured Analysis of Journalistic Evaluations for News Source Reliability
论文作者
论文摘要
在当今的信息障碍时代，许多组织正在努力验证网络和社交媒体上发布的新闻的真实性。特别是，一些机构正在探索在线媒体的世界，并通过大部分的手动过程对全球新闻来源的可信度和透明度进行排名。在本文中，我们评估了两种程序，以评估在线媒体将其读者暴露于M/虚假信息的风险。这些程序是由Newsguard和全球虚假信息指数决定的，两个著名的组织通过良好新闻业的实践来打击D/错误信息。具体而言，考虑到固定的媒体媒体，我们检查了其中有多少个程序被两个程序均等评分，哪些方面导致评估分歧。我们的分析结果表明了一定程度的共识，我们认为这具有双重价值：它使程序的正确性达到了自动化的基础。
In today's era of information disorder, many organizations are moving to verify the veracity of news published on the web and social media. In particular, some agencies are exploring the world of online media and, through a largely manual process, ranking the credibility and transparency of news sources around the world. In this paper, we evaluate two procedures for assessing the risk of online media exposing their readers to m/disinformation. The procedures have been dictated by NewsGuard and The Global Disinformation Index, two well-known organizations combating d/misinformation via practices of good journalism. Specifically, considering a fixed set of media outlets, we examine how many of them were rated equally by the two procedures, and which aspects led to disagreement in the assessment. The result of our analysis shows a good degree of agreement, which in our opinion has a double value: it fortifies the correctness of the procedures and lays the groundwork for their automation.
