论文标题
以人为本的对美国儿童福利系统中使用的算法的评论
A Human-Centered Review of the Algorithms used within the U.S. Child Welfare System
论文作者
论文摘要
美国儿童福利系统(CWS)被控改善寄养青年的成果;然而,他们负担沉重和资金不足。为了克服这一限制,几个州已转向算法决策系统,以降低成本并确定改善CWS结果的更好过程。使用以人为本的算法设计方法,我们综合了50个对CWS中使用的计算系统的同行评审出版物,以评估它们的开发方式,所使用的预测变量的共同特征以及目标结果。我们发现,大多数文献都集中在风险评估模型上,但不考虑理论方法(例如,寄养父母的匹配)或案例工作者的观点(例如,案例说明)。因此,未来的算法应通过结合过去的研究确定的显着因素来努力成为上下文感知和理论上的健壮。我们为HCI社区提供了研究途径,以开发以人为本的算法,这些算法将注意力转向CWS更公平的结果。
The U.S. Child Welfare System (CWS) is charged with improving outcomes for foster youth; yet, they are overburdened and underfunded. To overcome this limitation, several states have turned towards algorithmic decision-making systems to reduce costs and determine better processes for improving CWS outcomes. Using a human-centered algorithmic design approach, we synthesize 50 peer-reviewed publications on computational systems used in CWS to assess how they were being developed, common characteristics of predictors used, as well as the target outcomes. We found that most of the literature has focused on risk assessment models but does not consider theoretical approaches (e.g., child-foster parent matching) nor the perspectives of caseworkers (e.g., case notes). Therefore, future algorithms should strive to be context-aware and theoretically robust by incorporating salient factors identified by past research. We provide the HCI community with research avenues for developing human-centered algorithms that redirect attention towards more equitable outcomes for CWS.